The Astonishing Adventures of Fan Boy and Goth Girl
By Barry Lyga

Another bargain buy! I picked this one up on sale and on a whim. I was looking for something interesting outside of my usual reading preferences. This novel is about a young boy, comic book geek, jock punching bag who has only one friend. He’s a typical teenage boy, hates his mom, her new husband and his soon to be born half-sister, lusts after the hottest girl in school and creates a list of people who he’d like to kill if he had the chance, or the guts to, people who have wronged him. That is until he meets Kyra, a.k.a, Goth girl. Now, I knew some girls like this when I was a teenager, totally unhinged, disconnected from her parents, pissed off with the world, daring everyone to look at her and her ghostly white skin and black clothes, ready to scream at them if they starred too long and yet at the same time craving for some affection, so attention, someone to see her beauty. I can see how this character could be based on someone real. She had some real problems and real reactions. Some of the things that Kyra did however made me roll my eyes, firstly, because she is portrayed as a typical screwed up teenager with a few clichés thrown in to highlight the point and secondly because she is clearly written by a man. Not to say that Lyga didn’t do a good job with his characterization but some of the things she says and does are a little too typical a little too cliché.
I liked the story; I wasn’t really keen on the ending, not totally satisfying. Strangely I found myself connecting with the narrator in a bizarre way; the bullying aspect was very real for me and very true to life. Many people overlook the bullied, don’t see what is happening, don’t pay attention to the signs or simply don’t know how to help. I get that. Lyga nailed the emotions connected to bullying quite well.
Part of the plot revolves around the narrator’s goal to get a graphic novel he’s been working on read by one of his idols. In the end he is faced with a rejection which he calmly accepts, which I didn’t find totally believable. I’ve seen teens not get what they really want, what they’ve been working toward for a long time; usually they do not react in a calm manner. But whatever, it’s a novel right?
And then there’s the part that made me squirm. The bullied becomes the bullier. This is something that happens more than most people realize. The problem is that the narrator turns on his principal in a way that glamorizes lying and falsely accusing an adult of horrible things. I didn’t like that. I don’t think it’s acceptable to write about a character triumphing partly because he blackmails an educator with false accusations. That crap happens more than people know and it destroys innocent people’s lives. So, I wasn’t cool with that part of the novel.
Review by Angela Minchella